Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Hessian's avatar

I can ask him if he’d like to make an acc here, although I doubt he’d post much after just a few interactions with this app’s users.

Expand full comment
CritterEnthusiast's avatar

Germanic religion isn’t undeveloped because it doesn’t have a kind of priority monism/cosmophysicism that other IE religions have, but just in general, much of the Germanic religion is undocumented or its finer more nuanced details were only recorded in extremely esoteric druidic circles. I don’t think thats controversial to say, in comparison to the iranic complex beliefs, there is a lot thats left unexplained or not elaborated upon. We never got to see a fully fleshed out system of karma or any ideas of enlightenment due to Christianity. We saw Odins sacrifice on the world tree in pursuit of esoteric knowledge but it wasn’t systematized or formalized like Hinduism and Buddhism. This is to the detriment of Germanic religion because contemporary practioners essentially just decide what the Germans believed and mix it into their Nietzschean or Esoteric Hitlerist belief systems. While “paganism” in general is more decentralized than abrahamic religions, its not good to lack a Orthodoxy or general frame of reference to identify it with. There are plenty of “norse pagans” who basically have a materialistic worldview despite the unlikelihood of ancient Germanic people sharing those ideas.

It’s either reconstructed with Platonism or Hinduism or remains in a kind of dry polytheistic state without much elaboration or explanation cosmically or metaphysically speaking. I think that IE peoples who became sedentary earlier in their history had more time to reflect on things like death, ascension and existential problems like suffering or the incompleteness found in the current configuration of consciousness. We kind of have an indeterminate development and only conjecture exists to determine these finer attributes.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?